Whenever people ask me how many cookbooks I have, and I give the usual noncommital reply, the next question is always, "Why do you have so many?" I’m not exactly sure why, to be honest. All I know is that when I come across a cookbook that I like, I feel an almost immediate bond or connection. I’m happy to say that I have developed a very strong connection to Paulette Mitchell’s A Beautiful Bowl of Soup.
I’m so glad I made this book the Cream Puffs in Venice Flavour of the Month for March. It’s warm and simple and full of the wholesome, filling recipes that I enjoy making on weekends when I have time. The added bonus is that they are all fairly uncomplicated to make so they’re an excellent option for a weeknight dinner as well.
Thus far I’ve learned to make an incredible vegetable stock and black bean soup (check out Tea and Cookies and read Tea’s post about her version based on Mitchell’s recipe) and a surprisingly good red lentil soup. But there are so many incredibly inviting recipes. As I perused each one recently, I found myself having considerable difficulty deciding which to make next. And then I turned the page and saw a recipe for Caramelized Onion Soup.
So here’s where you learn something new about Cream Puff: I have never had onion soup. Never. I think I surprised myself when I realized this. Since this blog is all about realizing all the little food dreams that I have and pushing myself to expand those food horizons, I thought that there would never be a better time than now to finally take the proverbial plunge into that bowl of onion soup.
My understanding of traditional french onion soup is that it’s made with a base of beef broth and onions that have been cooked down to a caramelly softness. The final touch is a piece of country bread that is topped with Gruyère and then broiled. Mitchell’s recipe uses vegetable stock as opposed to beef stock. Fortunately I had some on hand in the freezer. Her recipe also calls for three different types of onion: sweet onion, red onion and shallot. I had red onion and shallots in my pantry (always do), but I needed to pick up some sweet onion.
This of course highlighted the fact that I don’t know very much about sweet onions. After much "googling" and "wikipediaing", I learned that the most common sweet onions are Vidalia and Walla Walla. Sweet onions have a lower sulfur content and a higher water content than other onions. This explains why they are less pungent and taste "sweeter".
My local supermarket had a sweet onion called "Honey Sweet" from Mexico. Once I was back home with my ingredients, I set about putting together the soup. This brings me to another important point about Mitchell and her recipes: they’re easy to pull together. The only possible challenge this recipe could present is slicing the onions. Fortunately I have a mother who (un)willingly supports my kitchen gadget habit so I whipped out my mandoline and made short work of the onions.
I began cooking the onions down. While they cooked gently (Mitchell advises not to burn the onions as that makes them bitter), I defrosted my vegetable stock and got my bread and goat cheese ready. Once the onions had caramelized, I added dry red wine and the vegetable stock and let the soup simmer for about 20 minutes. While it simmered, I toasted my bread slices and then spread on the goat cheese mixture I had prepared. I popped them under the broiler for a minute. When the soup was ready I placed the crostini on top and voilà !
The soup was incredible! The onions were sweet, but not too sweet and the broth was rich. The vegetable stock and the wine went together so well. My only disappointment with this recipe is my picture, which doesn’t show enough of the great soup.
But at least I’ve finally had onion soup. I think I’m ready to conquer the French next!
Ciao!
Caramelized Onion Soup with Goat Cheese Crostini
Adapted from A Beautiful Bowl of Soup by Paulette Mitchell.
- 4 tablespoons unsalted butter
- 1 pound sweet onions, thinly sliced (about 6 cups)
- 1/2 pound red onions, thinly sliced (about 3 cups)
- 1/2 cup thinly sliced shallots
- 4 cloves garlic, minced
- 2/3 cup dry red wine
- 3 cups vegetable stock (see recipe here)
- 1 tablespoon minced fresh thyme
- salt and pepper to taste (I used 2-1/2 teaspoons of salt and 1 teaspoon of pepper.)
Melt the butter in a large pot. Add the onions and stir to coat the onions in butter.
- Cover the pot and cook the onions for 25 minutes over low heat; stir occasionally.
- After 25 minutes, uncover the onions, increase the heat to medium and cook for 15 minutes until the onions have become very tender and have turned light brown.
- Add the garlic and thyme and cook for 2 minutes.
- Add the wine. Increase the heat to high and cook, stirring often, until the liquid dissolves. Keep an eye on the onions and make sure they don’t burn.
Add the vegetable stock and bring to a boil. Reduce heat to medium, cover the soup and let simmer for 20 minutes.
- After 20 minutes, season according to taste.
- Top with prepared goat cheese crostini and serve or top with crostini (that have not been broiled yet) and place under broiler until goat cheese begins to melt and bubble. Be sure to use heatproof bowls.
- Enjoy!
For the goat cheese crostini:
- 1/4 cup goat cheese
- 2 teaspoons olive oil
- 1 garlic clove, minced
- 1/2 teaspoon fresh rosemary, minced (or whichever herb you prefer)
- a dash of salt and pepper
- 8 slices of country bread, sliced 1/2-inch thick
Combine all the ingredients in a bowl. Mash with a fork until smooth and spreadable.
- In a toaster or under the broiler, toast the bread for a few minutes until golden.
- Spread the goat cheese mixture evenly over the crostini. Place under the broiler for a few minutes until the cheese begins to melt and bubble. Place the prepared crostini on the soup and serve.
- Alternatively, you can spread the goat cheese mixture evenly on the crostini and place them on the soup which has been poured into heatproof bowls. Place the bowls of soup under the broiler until the cheese begins to melt and bubble.
Note: This recipe yields 4 generous servings. It can be made ahead and kept in the refrigerator for up to 2 days.







24 comments
Catherine
Wow! this looks amazing! I just got this soup book from the library- yippee!
verniciousknids
I’m so glad you’ve joined the onion soup side
Your photo looks delicious!
maura
ryn: thank you so much for the kind words! I’ve recently discovered your blog and I enjoy it a great deal.
Rorie
Sounds amazing. So unfair that sharing isn’t possible over the internet.:(
rob
Ivonne, I’m well and truly shocked that you’d never had French onion soup. The goat cheese alternative sounds yummy, by the way, but I’m not sure I’ll give it a try — bubbling, browned gruyere is very tempting.
I’ll be sad to see your soup making month end soon. Your soups have been wonderful, I’m especially grateful for the vegetable stock tips.
Paz
I’ve never had onion soup, either. I’ve got to try this!
P.S. Today, I picked up from the library: A Thousand Days in Tuscany, Regional Foods of Northern Italy and Regional Foods of Southern Italy by Marlena De Blasi. Not that I have time to read, mind you….
Sally
This looks (and sounds) soooooo good! I, too, have never made onion soup even though it is DH’s favorite. I’m ashamed. It looks so easy, there really is no reason not to make it. I like the thought of the goat cheese as opposed to the mozzorella. More of a flavor I imagine. Great post Ivonne. Thanks!
Rosa
Your soup looks very appetizing and the presentation is always perfect!
Cannella
In questo blog mi piacciono PERFINO le cipolle! Baci
Ivonne
Hi Catherine,
I’m so glad you took this book out of the library. I hope you enjoy it as much as I have!
Hi VK,
I too am glad to have come over to the onion side. I can’t believe what I’ve been missing all these years!
Hi Maura,
Not sure if your comment was meant for me or not … but if it was, thanks!
Hi Rorie,
Good point. We must work on technology that will allow us to send food via high-speed.
)
Hi Rob,
Yes. It’s true. I’ve never had onion soup. It’s an embarrassing admission to make and I almost didn’t put it on the internet for the whole world to see … but then I thought … how will I overcome the onion soup obstacle if I don’t admit it!
)
So glad that you’ve been enjoying the soups!
Hi Paz,
I know what you mean. I’ve got about 5 books that I’ve started and haven’t finished one of them. You have to let me know how the cookbooks are!
Hi Sally,
The goat cheese was really good although I’m going to have to try the original one day with gruyere!
Hi Rosa,
Thanks so much! I take that as a compliment coming from a great photographer such as yourself!
Buongiorno Cannella!
Veramente non sapevo se mi sarebbe piacuta questa zuppa siccome non amo veramente le cipolle. Ma infatti era buona!
Tanti saluti!
Mark - Nazca
Some recipes call for the onions to be coated in a little flour before adding the wine/stock. I prefer my soup a little thicker so I use this method. As you know, I used a mix of goats cheese and mozzarella on my pizza. Maybe a mix of gruyere and goats cheese would work here too
Jennifer
Ivonne, my first thought was “this photo is to die for!” This soups looks sooo good. Count me as one of your newest fans!
Ivonne
Hi Mark … goat cheese and gruyere … I like the way you think!
Hi Jennifer,
Thanks for stopping by. Glad to hear that you liked the soup!
vanessa
ah, a mandoline! that’s what i need
Jennifer
I love onion soup of all kinds! This one sounds (and looks) particularly yummy with the three different kinds of onions. If you ever see Vidalias, grab them–they’re sweetness is hard to beat.
Karina
Nothing like a sweet and savory onion soup! Beauty!
Ivonne
Hi Vanessa,
Yes! I highly recommend it!
)
Hi Jennifer,
Thanks for the tip. I will certainly keep my eyes open for them!
Hi Karina,
Thanks so much!
Bea at La Tartine Gourmande
Ah ahahm la soupe aux oignons. This is something to make a French girl happy! So is this what you make when you ship me to Toronto?
Delicioso!
Greg
I’m drooling over your picture.Being the beefy kinda guy I am I would use beef stock.Oh and Gruyere cheese.. I’m in food heaven
rowena
I am just swooning… having just come from Gluten-Free Goddess and her frittata with goat cheese and now this dee-lovely, dee-lightful onion soup (caramelized no less) with goat cheese crostini. Arghgh, and I thought I could just slip by and eat my $5.50, 5 1/2 oz. round of goat cheese on saltine crackers!
Ivonne
Cara Bea,
Yes we will do all in our power to make you happy!!!
Hi Greg,
As much as I’m liking the vegetable stock, I’m with you on the beef stock. I’ll have to try to make the original very soon.
Hi Rowena,
I know what you mean. I feel like I gain weight just looking at the pictures. Thanks for the sweet words!
Alanna
Gorgeous! Am I getting this right, you’ve been cooking/posting from one cookbook all monoth? What a great idea!
Ivonne
Hi Alanna,
You got it!
Kat & Satoshi
My stomach is growling!!