I am seriously behind with my posts about baking class. I promise I’ll catch up soon, but I’m just having too much fun baking and blogging about bread! Several weeks ago, in bread class, we were scheduled to make challah. Unfortunately, work commitments meant that I had to miss that class and I was more than disappointed. I love challah, and I especially love using it for bread puddings and French toast.
It was a stroke of luck then when I noticed that Linda Haynes had included a recipe for challah in her new cookbook, More from ACE Bakery. Excited and eager, I set about making challah for the very first time.
The process began with a starter (called a pâte fermentée), which I made the night before I planned to bake the challah. The starter consisted of water, yeast (traditional dry yeast), hard white flour and fine sea salt. Unlike other bread recipes where the yeast has to be developed before adding it to the flour and other ingredients, Haynes’ recipe for starter calls for everything to be combined in a mixer for a few minutes and then allowed to rest for 15 minutes. I was under the impression that only instant yeast could be added to flour in this way, but I guess I’m wrong. After the starter rested for 15 minutes, I kneaded it for an additional few minutes before placing it in a greased bowl to rise in the refrigerator overnight.
The following morning I found a starter that had more than doubled in size and had lovely bubbles and holes all over it. That was a clear sign that it had been fermenting. All those little bubbles represented the gas being created throughout the fermentation process.
To make the challah, I added water, yeast, hard white flour, semolina flour, egg yolks, honey, butter and sea salt to the starter. I mixed everything in the mixer using the dough hook and within minutes, I had a beautiful dough that was smooth and heavy. Once again, I let it rise for a few hours in a greased and covered bowl. At that point, I was ready to form my challah.
Haynes advises that if you’re intimidated of the entire braiding process, you can easily form your
challah into rounded loaves. But looking at the braiding illustrations, I felt reasonably confident that I could manage.
I divided my challah dough into 5 equal pieces, which I then rolled into strands. I lined the strands up and joined them at one end. I then moved two strands slightly to the left and the other three slight to the right. Over, across, over, across, repeat, repeat, repeat. I actually ended up with a decent braid! But my one mistake is that I rolled my strands a bit too long. As I braided the strands and struggled to move them out of the way, I inadvertently begin laying them over the edges of the counter. As I did this, the weight of the dough began to pull the strands downward, which meant they were getting longer and longer! Instead of a neat, compact braid, I ended up with a rather longish and skinny one.
I would have gone ahead and baked it that way except I was worried it wouldn’t fit on the baking
sheet so I did the logical thing (to me, anyway) and I turned my braid into a braided ring. I brushed the top with egg wash and let the dough rest to rise again for about 30 minutes. Another brush with egg wash and into the oven it went. About 30 minutes later I had a golden, eggy ring of pretty good challah if I may say so myself!
The only problem I had with the recipe was the honey. I don’t think I’ve ever seen challah recipes that call for honey so I was intrigued to see it on the ingredients list. But when I tasted the challah, I found that it tasted predominantly of honey which overwhelmed the buttery egginess that I enjoy in challah. Haynes’ recipe calls for wildflower or acacia honey and I used wildflower because that’s what I had on hand. If I made the bread again, I would omit the honey.
However, one thing bread class has taught me is that many breads require both a sugar as well as a salt. Yeast feasts on sugar so I’m guessing that if I omit the honey, I’ll have to replace it with another type of sugar. Clearly I need to research this further and just keep trying my hand at challah.
It’s a tough job but someone’s got to do it!
Ciao!








27 comments
peabody
That is odd that it had honey, but it looks beautiful.
maura
I remember forming challah loaves in culinary school. Yours is gorgeous. Mine looked like hell!
Tanna
I’m thinking you’ll find it’s one of those what you grew up with is the way it should be things.
Fun the way the ropes got longer. Another way I seen Challah shaped is with a length of fat ropes braided as the base and a length of thinner ropes laid on top.
Your Challah looks beautiful!!!
I posted my 24 hour bread, hope Baking Soda gets hers up soon.
fanny
Hi Ivonne,
your challah looks exquisite. I wish i could have some for breakfast.
The picture makes me drool!
And by the way i’m with you on the honey – i prefer my brioche to taste plain (in a good way)…
-fanny
Kat
ooh that looks so good! now I think I know why my bagels didn’t get too big, I didn’t have any sugar in there…thanks for sharing!
rowena
I LOVE challah, and darn if you didn’t just remind me of the challah that my jewish boss use to make at the deli. You know I can just smell it now?! I would rate it as total comfort food…yeah!
Ellie
Looks stunning! I’ve never had challah before, but have heard rave reviews about the soft buttery-ness of the inner crumb and how wonderful they are when used to french toast…perhaps I should give these a try!
Lydia
Your challah looks beautiful. I’m remembering the challah French toast on Saturday mornings when I was growing up. In fact, I wonder now whether my mother bought a challah every Friday just so we could have it left over for the Saturday breakfast!
Lisa
Ohh how I wish I had your challah yesterday morning when I made a french toast casserole!! Instead I used a store bought loaf and it didn’t hold a candle to the looks and (I’m 100% sure) taste of yours!
Question – what is hard white flour?
xoxo
Carrie S.
Yum – I love Challah, and being Jewish, grew up with it. Round Challah is typically served on Rosh Hashanah for the New Year. It’s delicious any way you make it and serve it.
By the way, try making french toast with it…no further explanation needed! XO
catherine
That’s the best challah pic I’ve seen. Wow – it looks perfect. Bravo Ivonne!
Brilynn
Beautiful challah indeed! I never get tired of your bread posts.
Nazca
Hey, we both been baking bread
Mine was of the garlic variety though
mimi
How lovely! Yes, I agree with everyone above — what a photo!
Helen
I love challah and anything from the brioche family. I could devour a loaf by myself.
Yours looks beautiful. Impecable job!
anna
I had a similar problem in my attempt at challah making as well. My braid became too long when I braided too tightly. One tip that helped me was to start braiding from the center of the braid instead of the end. Your challah does look fantastic!
Rosa
Your Challah looks wonderful!
I use honey when I make Challah and in my Joan Nathan book there is a “Chez Panisse” Challah that also uses honey. I guess that both sugar and honey are ok…
krista
Hallah bread is my favorite bread. I especially like using it for french toast.
Jann
This is beautiful-too nice to eat! I don’t know how you keep up with all this baking and cooking and still have time for the posts-you are a wonder woman!
Bea at La Tartine Gourmande
very nice! I would love a slice!
joey
I love challah! I have been bookmarking a bunch of recipes already and will attempt it soon! Your’s is absolutely lovely Yvonne…when I saw the first picture I thought for sure you were already a challah expert (because it had such a fancy braided ring shape) and was surprised when you said it was your first time!
sher
Your challah has a gorgeous color, not always easy to get it that perfect!
Sara
That Challah looks so tasty. I’ve never tried it before. These ACE books sound pretty darn good.
raesha
I love challah – this looks SO delicious!
aria
your breads are just beautiful. i might actually attempt to bake bread this thanksgiving. thx for all the inspiration
shelly
That’s a gorgeous challah. It looks like it would be really yummy lightly toasted with a little butter.
ejm
Your challah looks stellar!
I’ve only supervised the making of challah when one of my friends wanted her hand held as she made her first loaf of bread. None of my bread books had any challah recipes so I searched the internet to find “Grandma Rosie’s Fabulous Challah” recipe: http://www.williams.edu/Astronomy/kkwitter/challah.html
(I LOVED the title and photograph of Grandma Rosie and decided that her challah recipe just had to be correct.)
Alas, I could only stay long enough to see the bread come out of the oven. I told them to wait til it had cooled before tasting the bread. It looked beautiful! The next day, my friend reported that it was exactly like challahs she had eaten in the past and was a huge success. None of it was left. She and her family had scarfed up the whole large loaf.
I don’t remember absolutely, but I’m pretty sure that we used honey and I didn’t hear any complaints that the bread had too much honey flavour. The only negative comment (and it wasn’t really a negative comment but a “next time you make the bread, please add” sort of comment) was that we had decided against sprinkling the top of the challah with poppy seeds.
-Elizabeth