Move over, Martha. The Daring Bakers are claiming your territory!
Well, perhaps we’re not quite claiming your territory but we are all over a dessert you showcased. And it’s a good thing too as judging by my own experience and that of most of the other Daring Bakers, your recipe could do with a bit of help.
As many of you know, back in November Lis of La Mia Cucina and I decided to challenge ourselves to bake (or create) foods that we would normally not try. Since November, the little group that we affectionately named The Daring Bakers has grown to close to thirty members!
Each month our challenges have been exciting and we have been pushed to try new recipes and expand our creativity. But along with the growth spurt we’ve had some growing pains. Voting on our monthly challenge became a bit of a headache due to the number of people involved. As a result, we made a decision to move to a hosted event. Part of the duties of being hostess (or host) is that you must choose a challenge for the month, supply the recipe (and post the recipe on your own blog) and pick a date for the challenge.
The April edition of The Daring Bakers features Brilynn of Jumbo Empanadas as hostess. Brilynn had her eye on a Martha Stewart confection called Darkest Chocolate Crepe Cake. Martha’s own creation is based on a famous crepe cake from the New York bakery, Lady M Cake Boutique.
This particular dessert consists of four components: crepes, filling, glaze and decoration. While I have some experience with crepes, I was very intrigued by the idea of making chocolate crepes, which I’d never done before. The crepe batter, which included semisweet chocolate, was fairly straightforward to pull together. As I went to actually cook the crepes, however, I was a bit concerned as I know that some of my fellow Daring Bakers had experienced some difficulties.
While the first few crepes had their lives tragically cut short after tearing and generally not cooking properly, I found the rest of the crepes easier to produce. The only drawback to this part of the recipe was that it took so very long to make the crepes. This was partly my fault as I decided to make mini crepes. After some research, I "invested" in a $9 egg fry pan that has the most adorable handle ever! I don’t usually eat a lot of fried eggs but the pan was so cute that I couldn’t resist.
While the crepes were good, I didn’t find anything particularly exciting about them. So I looked to the filling to offer the pizazz factor for this dessert.
I studied the recipe for the filling in the original but knew right away that I didn’t want to make it. Have you ever looked at a recipe and thought, "You know what. I just don’t want to go to the trouble"? That’s precisely how I felt when I looked at the filling recipe. Did I really want to buy Hazelnut Cream? Did I really want to use six egg whites? Did I really want to use almost a pound of butter just for a filling? For some reason I just felt uninspired by the filling and decided it just wasn’t worth using up precious butter.
Instead, I decided to go the simple route by spreading Nutella on the crepes. I figure you just can’t go wrong with Nutella! After having filled and built my little crepe cakes, I put them in the refrigerator to set. While they rested, I made the chocolate glaze. This particular glaze was quite easy to make and definitely good, but again, there wasn’t anything spectacular about it. It had a great pour quality that definitely covered a multitude of crepe sins, but other than that it was your average chocolate glaze.
For some strange reason, the further into the recipe I got the less interested I felt.
The final step before putting it all together was the decoration. The original recipe includes instructions on how to make candied hazelnuts with a decorative effect. Initially I wasn’t going to make these as it seemed a lot of trouble, but I changed my mind. I reminded myself that part of being a Daring Baker is pushing yourself so I went ahead with caramelizing the hazelnuts. I’m glad I changed my mind. The hazelnuts were probably my favourite part of the recipe. I would be lying if I said it wasn’t great fun creating strings of caramel sugar all over the kitchen.
The fun of the hazelnuts aside, at this point I was just eager to put the cake together and see the final result (and get it over with). I cloaked the crepe cakes in the chocolate glaze and let them set for a few minutes before transferring the cakes to a serving dish and then finally cutting into one of them.
The cakes were sweet with a nice touch of hazelnut from the Nutella. And the caramel decorations were a big hit. However, if I were to make this again, I think I would make a cream filling. As good as the Nutella was, I think some creaminess would have helped to lighten the cake just a bit.
But to be very honest with you, I just don’t see myself making this particular crepe cake again. It was uninspiring. It tasted alright, but the taste doesn’t match the visual appeal of the cake. It’s hard to put my finger on it, but the end result just didn’t live up to the hype.
Having said that, my Daring Bakers have all acquitted themselves admirably. In fact quite a few of them have given Martha a run for her money! To see what incredible confections the other Daring Bakers produced, you can check their blogs by clicking on the links under The Daring Bakers category in the sidebar to the right of this page.
And stay tuned … The Daring Bakers will be back for more next month!
Ciao!
Note: For those of you interested in trying this dessert, there is a video demonstration that you can watch from the Martha Stewart site.
Technorati tags:
crepes,
crepe cake,
daring bakers









41 comments
peabody
Uninspiring….what a perfect word for this cake.
Tanna
But I just can’t imagine the Cream Puff being uninspired.
The filling really is butter but it somehow managed to be “light”, now that’s got to be the definition of oxymoron!
Beautiful!
breadchick
Amen Sister!! Uninspiring IS the perfect word. But the filling was good!
Brilynn
Wow! Your cake is so dark! And your sugar decorations are adorable with their little tails.
Ellie
Well, the cake LOOKS incredible, talk about making a statement – I think this is the equivalent of a dark and mysterious stranger! Ever so beguiling in the dark…but in the light (under close scrutiny), perhaps not so much
Elle
Dark and handsome cakes, and a smart move to forget that butter laden filling. The hazelnuts are so cute. It really is an uninspiring recipe, but it was an interesting challenge.
Jann
my gawd those are all fabulous-
Helen
Thanks for a great write up, could not have said it better. You are right, Nutell rocks and what a great way to make the cake stand out.
As always everything you wrote is right on the money.
Sara
Very adorable! I used nutella in the filling instead of the hazelnut cream, but your idea to just use nutella is much wiser. I think I could have eaten more if the filling wasn’t so rich. Wait a minute, it’s probably better that I didn’t eat more.
Kat
love it! your filling of nutella sounds wonderful!
Ari (Baking and Books)
I saw Martha make this on her morning show and was amazed by the finished results. Your cake looks just as perfect as hers did! Very good to know about the taste. Sorry it didn’t live up to your expectations but at least you got an impressive entry and a gorgeous photo out of the endeavour right?
Mary
I wanted to skip the filling and just spread plain jam on the crepes. But I decided to go ahead with the meringue buttercream filling and I’m glad I did. For me it was the best part of this cake.
I’m glad you continued and made the candied nuts since that turned out to be your favorite part.
Freya
I completely agree about the taste and getting bored with the cake as each element adds up. Yours still looks great though and the nuts look fab!
Pille
Sorry to hear that the cake disappointed you- it surely looks lovely on the top picture, with all those sugar decorations!
Clarene
Ooh if its constructed with layers of crepe than technically its fit for breakfast right?
Pasticciera
Your finished photo is inspired, but I would have to agree the crepe/nutella combo doesn’t inspire me, especially as fiddlelyas it seems to be. But as the old saying goes….nothing ventured nothing gained. I love the final presentation.
Laura
I had afeeling you were going to make little ones! I used Nutella in the buttercream filling and it was lovely but some of the nuttiness was definitely lost. They look lovely!
veron
love your cake! And you are right the filling was just too much work and did not promise any yumminess. A cream filling would definitely be a lot better…
Meeta
Ivonne, I was going for the Nutella idea too, but you know what I thought I need to impress these girls a bit and made a different filling too. But I know IF I ever make this cake again I think Nutella is the way to go! It looks wonderful (as I expected it would)!
gilly
Gorgeous, Ivonne! And I had to laugh at the egg-fry pan because I’m pretty sure I looked at the EXACT same pan when I was looking for something to make my crepes in! I love the Nutella filling, and your gorgeous sugared hazelnuts! Beautiful job!
ilva
Ivonne, I should have done like you and just put Nutella between the layers, maybe it would have stayed put then! Nice post!
Glenna
Doesn’t it make you wonder what all we don’t know about what happened behind the scenes in “Martha’s” kitchen when they made that cake to be photographed? And how much cussing was involved? I mean, come on. I used to be a cake decorator and after a while and experience, maybe it’s ego, but I now am suspicious of any cake recipe that causes 30 people that much trouble. I just have to wonder how much of Martha’s cake was a cheat…
Lydia
Your cake looks gorgeous (as always), but after reading your post I’m definitely not inspired to try it. Now I’m going to read through what the other Daring Bakers have written about it. I’m a vicarious baker (is there such a thing??!), and I’m having great fun reading about the exploits of this group. Please keep baking!
Jenny
Sorry about the drool but it is the only way I get to be that close to so much Nutela!
Nice work oh wise and wonderous founder!
Rosa
That looks gorgeously fabulous! I’d love to eat a slice of that yummy cake…
sher
I love the way your glaze looks! It’s so much prettier than mine, which was rather flat looking. I enjoyed the drama of making the cake, but I wouldn’t make this cake again for years. But, I have to admit, while I thought it was good (but not terribly memorable), it was my friends who went crazy over the taste. They liked (loved) it a lot more than I did. So they can make it next time!
:):)
Patricia Scarpin
Ivonne, this idea of spreading Nutella on the crepes is fabulous – as much as I loved the filling, I was hoping it to be a bit more “hazelnutty”, if that word exists.
Your cakes are adorable!
Cheryl
I love how you look at a recipe and change just the right parts. You did fantastic and it looks amazing.
Jen
I felt the same about the filling as you did! I should have just used Nutella too!! Good Job.
Columbus Foodie
I would have gone the nutella route myself, had my crepes actually turned out. There’s just something about a pound of butter in a filling that isn’t conducive to eating healthy, LOL.
It looks divine. Dark and luscious. Too bad it didn’t live up to the hype – but on appearances, I give it a 10!
Lisa
Now see.. to me, the chocolate and the nutella would have been delightful, regardless if it was heavy. Course being a chocolate fiend doesn’t help with good judgement. hehee!
I think your minis are adorable! And I LOVE your hazelnuts – the color is gorgeous!
Excellent job, my friend.
Hugs!
xoxo
Baking Soda
Oh Ivonne, if I wasn’t already stunned I am now!
I always thought Martha is great to watch but not to recreate…you did a great job, too bad all these hours of hard labour didn’t pay off in flavour!
Alison
This reminds me of the flat version of the Baumkuchen. Filled with apricot jam and covered with chocolate (and traditionally made on a spit so it resembles a log), it is baked as you brush layers of batter on top of the baked portion as time passes. I can’t find anything resembling the recipe I used right now, but I’m on a mission now (it’s been a while since I’ve made one).
jasmine
Reading so many of The DB posts on this one…my heart goes out to all of you….
Love the candied nuts…
j
ellen
My friend and I tried this one 2 weeks ago and really i feel the taste just doesn’t justify the time spent. There is..no depth to the taste, if you know what i mean. it doesn’t get better with each bite. far too sweet in my opinion too.
Wishing On Clovers
Wow, just wow!! I have had my eye on that for so long, but I am so nervous to try it! Yours is fantastic!!!! And the addition of Nutella…ahhh! I could stare at this for days!
Steamy Kitchen
I remember seeing this recipe, tearing it out of the magazine and stashing it somewhere. It did look time consuming, so I never as brave (or daring!) enough to attempt!
Chris
Holy Moly – yum!
Kristen
I wonder if Martha and her people have read what you all have done with her recipe. She should be impressed!
joey
Alright! Nutella!
I would have done the same…but yes, perhaps when it’s all together, with the chocolate crepes and the ganache, it might do with something creamier…It looks fantastic though!
Seth McGee
The only “uninspiring” thing about the author’s take on this recipe is their pour-and-dump mentality. Six egg whites and a pound of butter? Why not just use Nutella, right? I mean it’s the same thing, just, um, made with partially hydrogenated vegetable oil and cocoa binders… and what structural purpose could egg whites have, hmm?
I thought the Martha Stewart version of this cake looked ghastly, and I won’t contemplate the author’s half-hearted attempt, but I will leave y’all with this take-away: French cooking is about using the highest-quality ingredients in a very refined manner. There’s no such thing as “meeting it halfway.”
Pro tip: have at least 2 pans going so you can turn out crepes quickly.